| BEST EXCLUSIVE | Mammon - Spawn Series 30: The Adventures of SPAWN |
| BEST BOXED SET | Komodo Dragon Clan Series 4 Deluxe Boxed Set |
| BEST 12" FIGURE | 12-Inch Mandarin Spawn 2 |
| BEST POSE | Komodo Dragon Clan Series 4 Deluxe Boxed Set |
| BEST PAINT | Water Dragon Clan - McFarlane's Dragons Series 3: Quest for the Lost King
Locke - LOST Series 1 |
| BEST ACCESSORY | Crate - Bram Stoker's Dracula 2-Pack Boxed Set |
| BEST PACKAGING | LOST Series 1 |
| BEST REPRESENTATION | McFarlane's Military 4 - Navy Seal Sniper |
| BEST LIKENESS | Locke - LOST Series 1 |
| BEST ONLINE FEATURE | LOST Series 1 |
| BEST LINEUP | NFL 14 |
| BEST BOXED SET | Roger Clemens Collector's Edition |
| BEST EXCLUSIVE | Hockey Rink |
| BEST CHASE/SURPRISE FIGURE | Randy Moss 3 (Vikings Afro chase) - NFL 13 |
| BEST POSE | Henrik Lundqvist - NHL 13 |
| BEST LIKENESS | Walter Payton - NFL Legends 2 |
| BEST SERIES | NFL |
| NON-SPORTS | Locke - LOST Series 1 |
| SPORTS - LEGENDS | Walter Payton - NFL Legends 2 |
| SPORTS - MODERN | Steve Smith - NFL 14 |
